We hope you love the products we recommend! Growing Herbs For Beginners is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission from Amazon. Learn more

Best Organic Lawn Fertilizer Reviews: Why Do Many Users Love Scotts?

0 968

You are seeking some help in making your lawn greenest. In this case, a fertilizer will become a helpful companion for you. That said, to choose the best organic lawn fertilizer is not an easy job as there are a bunch of brands, styles and types out there.

To make everything easier for you, growingherbsforbeginners.com have compiled a list of great options below for your consideration. We believe that with the right organic fertilizer, you could get the best results for your lawn.

What Is The Best Organic Lawn Fertilizer?

#1: Scotts Turf Builder Lawn Food

The first option we would like to share with you is the Scotts Natural Lawn Food. This fertilizer stands out among other products thanks to its ability to cope with any weather conditions. Thereby, you will not need to worry about whether it is ok to use it in a specific time.

It is safe to say not only does the product strengthen the lawn, but it also reduces future problems.

Plus, what we are impressed with this fertilizer most, which is also a point that outweighs other competitors, is that it could create deeper and stronger roots. You know, this will make your lawn much more resilient.

Furthermore, it acts as a helpful supporter for the absorption of nutrients and water in comparison to a super natural lawn.

Scotts Turf Builder Lawn Food

Another plus point of the Scotts Turf Builder Lawn Food is that it features the company’s exclusive All-in-One particle tech to make sure a consistent healthy lawn.

Unlike other fertilizers, it is used for any types of grasses. Therefore, you can rest assured that it will manage to make your lawn better in case you do not know what grass type you have.

In sum, this fertilizer is a perfect all-rounder since it can be used in all seasons. If you want to a type of fertilizer only for all the time of the year, it might be the one for you.


  • Can be used in any weather
  • Boost the lawn health and reduce problems in the future
  • Create deeper and stronger roots
  • Support the lawn to absorb water and nutrients
  • Curb with all types of lawn

Cons: None

#2: Miracle-Gro Water Soluble Lawn Food

Unlike the Scotts Turf Builder Lawn Food, the runner-up on our list is only for use in April and September. We highly evaluate the ability of this fertilizer to make your lawn more vibrant in these warmer months.

Another notable feature of this product is that it is quite easy to apply straight from watering, leading to an even distribution of fertilizer. You know, thanks to that, your lawn could be fed and watered simultaneously, which saves much time.

What we also liked about the Miracle-Gro Water Soluble is that it could make the lawn grow greener and more vibrant in less than a week. Thereby, you will not need to deal with weeds since the seeds are grown in the gaps in which the grasses are thinner.

Plus, as this product can be dissolved in water, there are fewer risks of scorching in the summer heat.

Miracle-Gro Water Soluble Lawn Food

Furthermore, the highlight of the fertilizer is that is can offer coverage of 7,200 sq ft while that of the first choice is just 5,000 sq. ft. This is a winning point of the Miracle-Go.

Notably, it is particularly formulated for chelated-iron and high-nitrogen turfgrass. So if you are growing turfgrass, this option might be the ideal one for you.

Though this fertilizer comes with various outstanding features, it could not beat the Scotts Turf Builder Lawn Food when it comes to making your lawn green and healthy. And as mentioned above, it can only work in warm months, not all the time as our top pick.


  • Easy to apply straight from watering
  • Get the results in less than a week
  • Offer fewer risks of scorching in hot conditions
  • High coverage
  • Specially designed for turfgrass


  • Lower performance in comparison with the Scotts Lawn Food
  • Be used in warm months only

#3: Milorganite 0636 Organic Nitrogen Fertilizer

Another suggested organic fertilizer is the name from Milorganite – the 0636 Organic. This is a nitrogen fertilizer that primarily includes heat-dried beneficial microbes and 4-percent non-staining iron. Thereby, you can rest assured than your lawn will grow healthier and greener than before.

And as it does not contain salts, it is safe to use in the dry conditions, and it will not contaminate groundwater and wells.

The highlight of this product is that it comes with a 5-2-0 NPK formula. Notably, the fertilizer is mainly created for a lush green lawn, along with various types of plants such as flowers, trees, and vegetables.

Milorganite 0636 Organic Nitrogen Fertilizer

Similar to the above options, the Milorganite 0636 could cut the need for watering, so that you will not have to water your lawn frequently and save energy costs.

Plus, it could even cut down mowing time significantly thanks to an exclusive slow-release formula, which is a feature that other models cannot beat.

You might not know this, but this fertilizer is used on numerous golf course for decades. This somehow proves the prestige and quality of the Milorganite 0636. When it comes to the price tag, this option is also a better deal for your consideration.

Nevertheless, one point that lets us down is that this product is not a good one for the root and plant growth like two first options. Also, it provides coverage of only 2,500 sq ft only while you know, the Scotts Turf Builder and the Miracle-Go respectively comes with the coverage of 5,000 sq ft and 7,200 sq ft.


  • Used on the golf course for decades
  • More affordable
  • Cut down mowing time and watering
  • Exclusive formula for greener and healthier lawn


  • Low coverage of only 2,500 sq ft
  • Not ideal for the growth of grass roots

#4: Super Juice Soluble Supplement Lawn Fertilizer

Next up is the all-in-one Super Juice fertilizer. We would say it actually earns the name as well. What’s unique about the Super Juice fertilizer is that it is an ultra-fine dry mix. That means you will have to mix it with water and apply to your lawn with a sprayer.

Everything is excellent with this fertilizer, yet its highlight lies in the fact that each pack of the Super Juice can cover up to 43,560 sq ft. Such an amazing figure that almost no product could compare with.

Super Juice All in One Soluble Supplement Lawn Fertilizer

Plus, at full strength, the fertilizer’s formula comes with a 14-2-4 NPK ratio. But its power can be halved with a 7-2-2 ratio as well. Thereby, you could store the unused part for the next application with no worry about waste and contamination.

Another plus point of the Super Juice fertilizer is that the nutrients contained can be quickly absorbed via the blades. And you will see the results within 1-4 hours, which is quite faster than various other products.

Any cons? We would say Yes to this question. First, this product comes with a quite higher price than those of other fertilizers. Also, we find that the application with this Super Juice is difficult. We have to try various sprayers.


  • High coverage of 43,560 sq ft
  • Quickly-absorbed nutrients
  • Fast results


  • Expensive
  • Difficult to apply

#5: Safer Brand 9334 Lawn Restore Fertilizer

Our last pick is the Safer Brand 9334 Lawn Restore Fertilizer. This is an organic fertilizer with 10-0-6 ratio. It is safe to say this product could offer a perfect balance of organic matters within the soil.

After applying this fertilizer, you could see the results within 3-5 days, at that time, your lawn will look brighter and healthier.

As its name suggests, it could restore the health of your lawn by providing numerous nutrients based on plants to the soil without poultry filter, biosolids, and manure.

Safer Brand 9334 Lawn Restore Fertilizer

The point that this product becomes more prominent than other products is that it could strongly promote the growth of the root system so that your grasses will be much healthier than ever.

The exclusive feature of this fertilizer is that it could fuel the beneficial organisms in the soil so that the plants could absorb essential nutrients for their growth better.

Last but not least, with the Safer Brand 9334 fertilizer, you could get comprehensive care for your lawn all the year as it helps the grasses resist cold, drought stresses, and heat.

That said, it does not appear to be perfect at all. There are several points in this fertilizer that need to be improved. For instance, its smell is so bad that we could hardly withstand though it is said to be odorless. Besides, it is a bit more expensive than other products.


  • Chemical-free formula
  • Greatly restore the health of the plants
  • Boost the root growth
  • Enrich beneficial organisms in soil


  • Bad smell
  • Slightly expensive

What To Look For When Buying The Best Organic Lawn Fertilizer?

So now you know our best organic lawn fertilizers, yet hold on! There are several vital points that you need to know before making the final decision. Let’s check them out!


Generally, there are three major kinds of organic materials. They deliver a different amount of minerals as well as release nutrients to your lawn. Here they are:

Plant-based fertilizer

Though this kind of lawn food does not last as long as other options, they are the best method to condition the soil. The key benefit of the plant-based lawn food is that it can help dry soils to hold onto water. Plus, it regularly uses bases of molasses, legumes, cottonseed meal, compost, and alfalfa meal.


This type of lawn fertilizer comprises of things such as manure, bone meal, and blood meal. They provide much nitrogen to the soil. They are also ideal for the start of a season and when you just seed the lawn.


Easily-found mineral-based lawn fertilizers are Epsom salts and Calcium that can add essential nutrients to the soil as well as change the pH. Also, this kind of fertilizer is the best choice to boost the growth of the plant.

top-rated organic lawn fertilizer

Formula ingredients

When you are considering an organic lawn fertilizer, initially, you should check its formula to see the main ingredients of this product. In case you are concerned about the fertilizer smell, it would be best if you stay away from animal-based lawn feeds.

You might not know this, but the worst smelling lawn food normally contains blood metal or chicken manure. On the other hand, if you do not care about the above temporary odor, they might be ideal choices.

Plus, if you are a vegan, you should check the key ingredients to check whether the product in question contains animal products. There is a bunch of types of organic lawn feeds out there that make use of natural alternatives not derived from animals.

Read more:  Top 8 Best Orchid Fertilizer For Your Plants in 2022

Application way

For the best results of the fertilizer, you’d better consider which application method is the best one for you, and then pick up a kind of lawn food to be applied in this method. Some lawn fertilizers could be applied by hand while some are by handheld sprayers. Meanwhile, some could even be hooked up to trailer sprayers for big areas of lawn.


Natural fertilizers are inevitably more expensive than chemical fertilizers. Therefore, to make every dollar count, you need to calculate your garden size correctly to figure out the amount of lawn feed you need to enrich the entire yard. Plus, it will help decide which choices are the best for your budget.

best organic fertilizer for lawn


Is organic lawn fertilizer better than synthetic fertilizer?

It depends. If you want to get the results in the fastest way, the synthetic fertilizer might be the right one. Otherwise, if you are not in a rush to provide lawn food, it would be better if you go for organic lawn fertilizer to offer benefits to soil and plants without damaging the surrounding environment and plants.

When should I put down organic fertilizer?

It would be best if you apply organic lawn fertilizers several weeks before planting. You could do one in late fall to ensure the soil is ready for the next crop.

Can you put down too much organic fertilizer?

We would say No to this question. Before applying any kind of fertilizer, you need to figure out the kind of lawn you have and the amount of fertilizer that the soil needs. Too much natural lawn fertilizers might burn the root system of the plants and make them more vulnerable to diseases and insects.

Final Thoughts

That’s all about the best organic lawn fertilizer we want to share with you. In a nutshell, organic lawn food brings many benefits to the soil, plants as well as the environment.

Do you have any option in your mind? If yes, we hope you will get the best result with it. If not, we suggested you choose our top pick – the Scotts Turf Builder Lawn Food as it could be used any period of time of the year and deliver the incredible result for the lawn.

In the end, do not forget to leave your ideas in the comment box below. Thank you for reading!

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.